The reason he makes this move is that male language is "revealed" in the Bible, while female language is us making it up, ie one is God's self revelation, the latter is a form of idolatry. Leaving aside the question of revelation, it's clear that the Bible does use feminine language, describing God like a mother bear, Jesus compares himself to a mother hen, etc. Of course what is more interesting is the wide range of language used in the Bible and the tradition.
God is the living water, we sing of God as a mighty fortress, as the wind, and so forth. If we want to avoid idolatry, the best route is to throw open the doors on the language we use, so we don't imagine that any one phrase captures God. If we become wedded to a particular language, that language and not what it points to, becomes the focus and then the game is up.
I wanted to highlight a few news items: The National Council of Churches, along with a wide range of religious groups, comes out against torture. Sadly enough, I could find no evangelical church who has been willing to take a similar stand, and the church's witness is accordingly weakened in the face of such an evil. And Kofi Annan calls for a conference on religious pluralism as a means to fight increasing extremism, an important goal.


3 Comments:
You'd all do well to remember that male & female are of God, not the other way round.
Linguistically, in English the most generic pronouns we have are masculine (not male).
You stated "And Kofi Annan calls for a conference on religious pluralism as a means to fight increasing extremism, an important goal".
Kofi Annan went on to say the following in trying to calm fears about religious extremism. "We must also unite in our efforts to address the extremism that is, alas, on the rise not only in Islam but among adherents of many faiths."
Even though he is correct in addressing religious extremism, he should go to Baghdad, Tehran, and several other Middle East countries first.
Launching into a chastisement of all religions misses the point. Islam is promoting violent terrorist attacks upon the world. Suicide bombers are not Lutherans, Catholics, or Baptists. They are Muslims.
It would be wise to focus on the problem, not broad brush everyone with a general "Diversity and Tolerance" message.
Tim, you may be superhumanly able to separate out "generic" masculine pronouns from the assumption of maleness, but psychological studies show that those of us mere mortals are incapable of doing so. When an average person hears a supposedly generic masculine pronoun, that pronoun activates male associations in the mind. Perhaps you are not average, but I think the church should recognize how normal people are influenced by these supposedly generic pronouns.
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home